The playlist · Best read after the last chapter

Worth It

A note on how to use this: the songs below are ordered to track the book, not to be listened to straight through as a mood. If you want to avoid spoilers, come back after.

Six Years of Being Awful About It

“Bad Idea Right?” — Olivia Rodrigo

The exact energy of two people who know better and are going to do it anyway. Jo furious with him and completely unable to look away.

“I Wanna Be Your Slave” — Måneskin

Not the antagonizing — what’s underneath it. An escalating list of every single thing he’d be willing to be for her, not one item of which he has ever said out loud.

“Locksmith” — Sadie Jean

Her side of the gym, three rows up between her dad and his mother. She doesn’t confront him, doesn’t cry, doesn’t even tell Nolan — she just starts “putting a layer between Beckett Hayes and her heart.” Brick by brick, a wall that takes six more years and a visitor parking pass to come down.

“What A Time” — Julia Michaels ft. Niall Horan

Beckett looking back past all of it — “a time before the pranks. Before the parking spots and the stolen hair ties and the nickname he’d worn out through sheer repetition. Before her shoulders tensed up.” Six inches of space where there never used to be any, and he is the one who put it there.

“Dandelions” — Ruth B

Six years of wishing for a thing he has never once asked for out loud.

“One Call Away” — Charlie Puth

How Beckett sees himself, played perfectly straight — the one who turns up, the one she can always call. The book is less generous about it: “unable to stand the idea of her giving someone else a chance, dressing jealousy up as concern.” He helps her from a distance she can’t see, and tells himself that’s the brave version.

“Work Song” — Hozier

And underneath all of it, the truth about Beckett Hayes. Devotion that goes down to the dirt.

“Remember to Remember Me” — Isak Danielson

The porch, after the first photograph. He has one chance to explain himself, spends it on “mistakes were made”, and then stands there while she decides what kind of man that makes him.

“How Do You Sleep?” — Sam Smith

Her side of the same porch. Four days of scrolling back to one photograph, a mental tally of every time Scarlett’s name turns up near his, and then the worst of it said to his face: “Because apparently that’s who I am now.”

“Man I Need” — Olivia Dean

And then her, done being patient about it. Teasing, completely unembarrassed, and asking him in plain words to stop being so hard to read — which is where six years of this finally runs out of road.

The Good Weeks

“In Case You Didn’t Know” — Brett Young

The confession. Six years of not saying it, one question he can’t dodge, and then he says all of it at once.

“Sweet Creature” — Harry Styles

Two people who have known each other their whole lives finally being gentle about it.

“That Part” — Lauren Spencer Smith

Five weeks in and already at the house and the kids, daring anybody to tell him the pace is crazy. Six years of running this film in his head and no ability whatsoever to be casual now that he’s standing in it.

“Babydoll” — Jamie Miller

October. The toothbrush. A boy sitting in his truck outside a drugstore, stupidly pleased with himself.

“You’re The Love of My Life” — Sam Tompkins

Her apartment. The first time. Every year he spent being awful about it, owned out loud and turned into a promise about staying — two days before anything tests one.

“Too Good to be True” — Kacey Musgraves

The same night, from her side. Asking him not to make her sorry she opened back up a part of herself she’d spent six years keeping shut, and braced the whole time for the floor to go.

“Beautiful Things” — Benson Boone

Six years of wanting this and now having it, and the low animal terror of knowing it can be taken away.

“Too Much to Ask” — gavn!

A boy who spent six years certain he’d forfeited the right to any of this, now waking up in it and quietly terrified that if she looks at him too closely she’ll leave.

“Something in the Orange” — Zach Bryan

Slipped in early on purpose. Something’s coming.

October, and What He Couldn’t Say

“Daylight” — David Kushner

The Delt house. A second door standing partway open and a boy who will spend the next five months at three in the morning trying to unsee it.

“Klonopin” — Caleb Hearn

The drive to the appointment, and every week after it. A highway, a silence he can’t fill, an office sitting between a dental practice and a tax place. He will choose her comfort over Jo’s trust — “over and over again”, as Nolan puts it later — and every time, it holds for a little while and then tears open.

“People Pleaser” — Kyle Hume

Beckett, exactly. A boy who says yes to everyone who asks him for something and has never once stopped to ask what it costs him.

“Kingdom of Fear” — Cameron Whitcomb

“I’m fine.” Five months of saying it to everyone who asks, refusing to be anybody’s burden, and one bad night where he admits he’d like somebody in his corner before he puts the face back on.

“Lie To Girls” — Sabrina Carpenter

Her side of October. Every excuse he hands her, set against every chance she’s willing to give him — and no ugly truth she can’t bend into something she can live with. She knows exactly what she’s doing. She does it anyway.

“If You Only Knew” — Alexander Stewart

The same conversations from his side of them, watching her decide.

“More Than A Man” — gavn!

Five months of walls, and the shame holding them up. He knows exactly what the silence is doing to her and he keeps it anyway, because the truth would change the way she looks at him: “I’d rather have you looking at me with suspicion than disgust.”

“Devil In Disguise” — Marino

A courteous stranger who warns you about dangerous men, walks you safely home, and empties your bag on the way. Beckett has been looking at a frightened six-year-old for thirteen years and falling for it every single time.

“Burning Down” — Alex Warren

And the other half of her. Taking the blame for fires she set, while she walks the whole house away from it on a story — and prays over him in public the entire time.

“I’m Not Calling You A Liar” — Florence + The Machine

The library carrel, her face six inches from a photograph of her boyfriend with another girl in his lap. “A picture that would support whatever you brought to it, and Jo had brought six years.” She lets the whole six-year-old script run all the way to the end — which is new — and then chooses him anyway.

“Burning House” — Cam

Jo on his front steps in the cold, choosing him over her own instincts — every day and on purpose — and making sure he knows it isn’t free. “All this mess with Scarlett and her pictures isn’t going to be the thing that breaks us. I’ve decided.” His phone buzzes in his pocket. He doesn’t look at it.

Three Months

“Secrets” — Regard, RAYE

The coffee shop. Two girls at the next table, a phrase she has only ever heard in his voice on his own porch, and a pregnancy attached to it. She packs up with hands that don’t shake and walks past them without turning her head. One week after “I’ve decided.”

“Too Good At Goodbyes” — Sam Smith

Six years of evidence, and the week it finally reads as proof. Every photograph, every excuse, every time he chose Scarlett — and she never once let him see what it took to keep choosing him over her own case.

“Love in the Dark” — Adele

Her side of the living room. Asking him not to look at her, because being looked at is the one thing that would make walking out impossible.

“Just Pretend” — Bad Omens

The first week. Telling her that what she thinks of him doesn’t frighten him, holding a completely calm face while admitting he isn’t okay, and offering to wait however long it takes and stay out of her way while he does it.

“Poison” — Dean Lewis

The rumor. True pieces arranged into a lie and circulated until he’s the one holding the blame for it, handed to two hundred people who never once asked where it came from.

“Lie, Lie, Lie” — Joshua Bassett

All the smaller ones, running the whole year underneath the big one. On again, off again. A photograph where she’s standing an inch closer to him than she really is. A friendship with Nolan twisted into something else and let loose. Jo settles it eventually without raising her voice: “most of these rumors started with one person. And I can promise you, none of them were true.”

“Serotonin” — JESSIA

Refusing to let the one person she let all the way in see what it’s doing to her. Her friends are tired of her. On the bad days she suspects she earned it.

“Better Days” — Will Swinton

The nights, January into February. He said the loving part out loud constantly once he started — he’d decided he would be the one to say it first, and then again after every phone call and every time they parted. It was the other thing he couldn’t say, and that’s what cost him.

“numb” — Sam Tompkins

Not the guilt — the wish to feel nothing at all. Four exams he can’t remember sitting, handwriting he doesn’t recognize, and nine hundred decisions not to pick up his phone.

“Forever & Again” — The Kid LAROI

Day five, and his mother stops him at the kitchen door. She doesn’t ask what happened. She asks where Jo is — and that’s the question that takes him apart, in the same chair and on the same shoulder as the first time he lost her, at thirteen, in that same kitchen.

“Call Your Mom” — Noah Kahan

The twenty-third. Nolan comes through the bedroom door without knocking and doesn’t go home. Beckett has spent weeks making himself nobody’s problem, and his best friend isn’t having it.

“Alive (it’s a lie)” — Kyle Hume

Back on campus, where everybody can see him. Lanie is glad of it at first — “He doesn’t get to look fine” — right up until Jo says it out loud: he isn’t sleeping, and he’s lost a lot of weight in a month. Something in Lanie’s face flickers. Nobody at that table knows the half of it.

“All Your Lies” — Dean Lewis

February, her apartment, after a week spent deciding how to say it. He stops asking and starts counting: “Five months is enough, Scarlett. You’ve got until spring break to give me the green light. After that, it stops being yours to decide.” Then he takes her up on something she offered him once in a church parking lot, and goes.

“Blame’s on Me” — Alexander Stewart

He never once defended himself. Not to the campus, not to Nolan, not to her — because the only defense he had belonged to somebody else.

“not my job anymore” — Thomas Day

Not the relationship — the small jobs. The late calls, the rides, the scrunchies in the console. Six years of work nobody ever assigned him, and no standing left to do a single piece of it.

“Anti-Hero” — Taylor Swift

The list, written out and read three times, refusing to settle. Three months of not sleeping over two theories with the same shape. “Had she decided he’d chosen another girl over her because the evidence said so, or because that was the blow she’d been braced for her whole life?” And then the answer she least wants: “Am I the one who actually sucks here?”

“The Hard Way” — Cameron Whitcomb

Nolan says it in the plainest words anybody uses in this book — “you get to be noble instead of terrified” — and all Beckett has back is “I know.” Twice. His mother told him. Nolan told him in the truck. He still takes the longest way around that there is.

“Some Things I’ll Never Know” — Teddy Swims

Three months of two people grieving in separate rooms, neither with any idea what the other was doing. She never found out he’d fixed the bracelet. He never found out she couldn’t throw the toothbrush away.

The Telling, and After

“Just Us” — James Arthur

The decision. Not the telling yet — the moment before it, where he decides that he’s going to.

“Unsteady” — X Ambassadors

The kitchen counter, and the floor of his mother’s living room after. A man coming apart with his back turned because he can’t get through it otherwise, and a girl who holds on anyway.

“Fast Lane” — Scatterbrain

Afterward, to the one person who stayed. Owning all of the damage, admitting how long he’d been too frightened to say how bad it had gotten, and the fact that she absorbed every bit of it without having earned a second of it.

“Count on Me” — Bruno Mars

The lot outside Nolan and Jo’s complex, and then the cab of Nolan’s truck. A best friend who hadn’t decided yet whether he was speaking to him, and who had planned the party anyway.

“You First” — Paramore

The bench outside the library. Scarlett comes over to work her, then watches Beckett walk up wearing a smile she has only ever seen aimed at Jo — and her face twists into something ugly. Jo enjoys it, then feels bad for enjoying it, right up until Nolan settles the matter: “You be as petty as you want for as long as you want to.”

“Home” — Edward Sharpe & the Magnetic Zeros

Ice cream with Nolan, who makes her tell it again and not leave out a single detail. “Nolan, what happens when she shows up to the party?”

“Cry” — Benson Boone

Nolan, at the party, finally going off. Years of swallowing it around a girl who answers for everything she does by pointing at her own pain — and one bad second of wondering how much of it he let happen.

“At Your Worst” (Acoustic) — Calum Scott

The swing at the lake house in March, the night after the worst night of the year. His head in her lap, the party still going on behind them, and a girl who stayed for all of it.

“Love of My Life” — Dean Lewis

His side of the same swing. She tells him she’s angry, then starts talking herself out of being angry before she’s finished the sentence — and that, the temper she apologizes for too fast, is the part he loves best about her.

“Sun To Me” — Zach Bryan

Six-thirty the next morning, dawn through the blinds, her hair in his face and his arm dead underneath her. He decides on the spot that he is never moving again, and manages fourteen minutes. Then he crosses her dark apartment and finds he still knows, after three months away, exactly where to step so the coffee table doesn’t get him.

“BIRDS OF A FEATHER” — Billie Eilish

A key in a velvet box and an empty drawer. And underneath it, a girl insisting she sees him clearly while he keeps trying to talk her out of it.

“Ordinary” — Alex Warren

The last chapter. An ordinary day made holy on purpose — two popsicles on a back step and a gate nobody ever fixed.

No lyrics are reproduced here — just titles, artists, and where they sit in the story. Go stream them properly; the artists deserve it. Every playlist I’ve made for these books lives on my Spotify at bit.ly/WynneSpotify, if you’d rather just hit play.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.